Strip poker turned into an unexpected sph

This happened in my college days. Our friend group had arranged a hang out at one of the dorms. Few people cancelled at the last minute so only three of us showed up - two girls and one guy. Let’s call him John. Coincidentally John was the only guy no girl from our group had hooked up with before.

There was not much to do so we just talked and kept drinking. Once the conversation died out, we heard a drunken “Let’s play strip poker!” from John. My friend and I looked at each other, I raised my eyebrow and she responded with a smirk. Being daredevils we did not hesitate and agreed to play, we were simply too drunk to care. 

Regarding the poker game itself - John had the worst luck in cards and very quickly ended up in only boxer shorts while my friend and I had only removed our socks. He didn’t even get to see us in underwear before losing another hand which meant it was time for him to get naked. We teased and laughed: “C’mon, let’s see what you're working with!”, expecting him to chicken out. 

He was beet red when suddenly he stood up, grabbed his boxer shorts and dropped them with finesse.

Both of us all went silent, it was the smallest dick I had ever seen. Not a micro penis, but extremely thin and very short. I wanted to laugh, but controlled myself, also it was still soft so I was giving him the benefit of the doubt. My friend on the other hand uttered: “Wtf, it’s so tiny”. I looked at her and she was holding her hand over her mouth as she did not mean to say that out loud.

To our surprise though, as soon as my friend said those mean words John got an erection - but his dick did not become much thicker and only gained an inch in length. There are growers and showers - John was neither.

“This is as big as it gets,” John said while looking at his tiny manhood. We giggled out of shock as we did not know how to react. 

“Omg, this is crazy!”, my friend without asking grabbed his tiny dick with two fingers and started examining it like we were at a science fair. John did not protest at all, his eyes rolled back and he started leaking precum.

After some more giggling I joined in on the “examination”, John started breathing heavily and looking up at the ceiling like he was trying not to cum. It must have been the first time in years someone other than himself had touched his dick. We were both just holding it when he started pathetically leaking cum, couldn't even call that a cumshot. We must have laughed for 10 minutes straight.

After our strip poker “incident”, thanks to my friend all girls knew John had a tiny pencil dick. He did not mind that at all, it was obvious he got off on it. Throughout college we would tease him about it and he was more than happy to indulge into the little dick jokes.